Curiosity Trek!
Prehistoric South Carolina | Curiosity Trek! Episode 5
Special | 27m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Ferocious Entelodont "Hell Pigs", Xenorophid ancient whales, and the Pelagornis sandersi bird!
Go WAY back in time and catch a glimpse into South Carolina’s wilder side with these fascinating prehistoric animals: The ferocious Entelodont “Hell Pigs”, ancient ancestors of dolphins called Xenorophids, and the Pelagornis sandersi seabird - the largest flying bird ever discovered in world history!
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Curiosity Trek! is a local public television program presented by SCETV
Support for this program is provided by The ETV Endowment of South Carolina.
Curiosity Trek!
Prehistoric South Carolina | Curiosity Trek! Episode 5
Special | 27m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Go WAY back in time and catch a glimpse into South Carolina’s wilder side with these fascinating prehistoric animals: The ferocious Entelodont “Hell Pigs”, ancient ancestors of dolphins called Xenorophids, and the Pelagornis sandersi seabird - the largest flying bird ever discovered in world history!
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Curiosity Trek!
Curiosity Trek! is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAndrew Davis> A ferocious "Hell Pig"... Ancient ancestors of dolphins... And the largest flying bird ever discovered in world history.
I'm Andrew Davis.
I'm a history enthusiast with passions for exploring and finding cool objects from the past.
But for me?
It's even cooler to find artifacts with remarkable historical ties.
The Palmetto State shares a rich culture and I'm here to tell its stories through the mementos left behind.
Join me on this journey as we uncover some of these historical stories.
This is Curiosity Trek!
The first stop on our journey into prehistoric South Carolina takes us to the Museum of York County in Rock Hill about an hour and a half from our home base in Columbia.
Around 38 million years ago, South Carolina was in what was known as the late Eocene era.
And then this era, a new, fearsome predator arrived on the scene.
It was big... It was aggressive, and it could deliver a nasty, bone crushing bite.
In its "Before the Ice Ages" exhibit, the museum has on display a replica of what one of these gnarly beasts looked like in its day.
This is the Daeodon, the largest of the Entelodont species.
And this species' nickname was "The Hell Pig".
Joining us to enlarge upon the life of these Hell Pigs is Curator of Natural History, Dr.
Steve Fields.
Steve Fields> I'm Dr.
Steve Fields, I'm the Curator of Natural History for the Culture and Heritage Museums.
Davis> Hey, Dr.
Steve, thanks for joining us today on Curiosity Trek!.
Fields> My pleasure, Andrew.
Davis> Now, in what time periods or years was the Entelodont alive?
Fields> Well, the time periods, late Eocene through the middle Miocene.
So you're talking about 38 million years ago up until about 15 million years ago.
The Entelodont came in.
at the end of what's called the Eocene epoch that would have been characterized by what you would call a hothouse or greenhouse climate.
Imagine, it's so hot that there are no ice caps at the poles, and the oceans are at an all time high level.
That's when they started.
Entelodonts probably originated in Asia and then migrated to Europe and over into North America.
Davis> What was the lifestyle like for the Entelodonts?
Fields> When you're dealing with fossils, behaviors are sometimes hard to figure.
But again, you compare it to animals that are alive today, maybe somewhat closely related.
Did the animal live in herds?
It's reasonable to assume they did.
We can't say for sure that they did.
And if one Hell Pig is intimidating, a herd of them would certainly be much more so.
Even if they were solitary, they would have spent the day foraging, looking for plants... You know, finding carcasses to scavenge, perhaps doing some active hunting on smaller animals as well.
Daeodon was the largest that have ever been found.
So they would have ranged in size from maybe pig-like creatures up into this size here.
They got to be this large, maybe a little bit larger, and on the order of 1,500 pounds.
There were some pretty ferocious predators in the Entelodont's day.
There were these carnivores.
They weren't cats, but they were saber-tooths.
They were called Nimravids.
And they were a cat-like group of carnivores.
And you also had some creatures called "Bear-Dogs", and you had some true dogs that were called "Bone-Crushing Dogs" because of their teeth.
So any of those might have at least attempted an attack on an Entelodont.
But more than likely, as I said, they probably preyed on the young or weak.
Davis> How many different kinds of Entelodonts are there?
Fields> Well, you know, paleontologists are going to have you know, arguments about this, but there were probably on the order of about 50 different species of these things globally speaking.
Davis> Aside from its massive size, the Daeodon entelodont's most striking features are its teeth, and its wide cheekbones.
Entelodonts were notorious for being highly-aggressive hunters and scavengers.
Now the question probably on everybody's minds: How did this creature earn the nickname "Hell Pig" or "Terminator Pig", where did that come from?
Fields> Well, just look at it!
*Chuckles* They were very fearsome, and if you'll pardon, perhaps if you were to encounter one of these things, what might be the first word out of your mouth!
Daeodon, which this species being portrayed here.
That's what it's called, Daeodon which, incidentally means "Hostile Tooth".
Entelodont actually means "Complete Tooth" or "Complete Dentition" and that comes from the fact that when you look at the skull and you look at the teeth, you see they have a full complement of incisors, canines, premolars, molars, you don't always see that in all of the mammals.
I've always been impressed by the the bony outgrowths on the head, and they are bone that's not flesh.
And so, what were those used for?
And there have been every hypothesis from just simply to make it look more intimidating to actually males, you know, butting their heads in rivalries.
Given their overall body mass and leg structure, they probably could have at least had short bursts of speed upwards of 30 mph.
Davis> So you would not want to be run down by one of these things.
Fields> No.
Definitely not.
*Chuckles* Davis> Despite Entelodonts resembling giant hogs, it may come as a surprise to some that they aren't even related to pigs at all!
Fields> The ancestors of Entelodonts would have appeared like pig-like creatures, somewhat smaller.
But they weren't true pigs.
They are actually more closely related to hippopotamus than anything living today.
They were used to be considered, closely related to pigs because they had a pig-like appearance.
But now we know that's really not the case.
Davis> Now, what factors led to the Entelodont's extinction?
Fields> By the time we get to the Miocene epoch of time, the climate is changing globally.
It's becoming cooler and it's becoming drier, and that's going to affect habitats.
Forests are generally disappearing in favor of, grasslands, or more open habitats, taking over most of the globe, not entirely.
But anytime you get major changes or shifts in climate and environment, if the animals can't adapt or migrate extinction is the only alternative.
and we think that's what happened with Entelodont.
The most productive fossil sites for Entelodonts in North America have been out west in what we would call the Badlands regions: Wyoming places like that.
But they have been found in other places- Florida and actually, one type of Daeodon have been found, or at least a partial fossil of a jaw have been found in South Carolina.
Davis> Where in South Carolina?
Fields> Dorchester County, that region close to maybe Charleston in what they call the Ashley Phosphate Beds along the Ashley River.
Davis> Dr.
Fields encourages visitors to come visit the York County Cultural Heritage Museum not just to see their Entelodont, but their other exhibits as well to capture multiple glimpses or "snapshots" into South Carolina's prehistoric times.
Fields> I hope that visitors come here and see not only this exhibit, but some of our others and they realize, you know what we see today in our "big backyard" is just a snapshot in time.
and that over millions of years, the Carolinas, the place we call home, have changed drastically.
And the creatures that have lived here are just, marvelous in the way they looked, the way they behaved.
Yes, there were dinosaurs here and everybody loves dinosaurs but, don't discount the large mammals that came after the dinosaurs.
Davis> Well Dr.
Steve, thank you for taking the time to talk with us today!
I really enjoyed our conversation.
Fields> My pleasure.
Andrew.
Davis> Although the Hell Pig was one of the top predators in this snapshot into South Carolina's history we hope you didn't find this visit... "Boar-ing" at all, did you?
I bet you'll never look at hippos in a zoo the same way ever again!
Now we transition from land to the sea.
Thankfully, this next family of prehistoric animals is much more graceful than the Hell Pigs!
Our second stop takes us on a three-hour trek down to the Mace Brown Museum of Natural History, in Charleston.
A long time ago, South Carolina's Coastal Plain regions were underwater.
During that time, ancient ancestors of dolphins lived exclusively in the southeastern region of North America.
These predecessors were called Xenorophids.
A rather unusual name for whales, don't you think?
But what exactly makes these whales so fascinating?
Two special guests join to guide us as we "dive" into the history of these ancient whales.
Persons> I'm Doctor Scott Persons.
I'm the Curator of Natural History at the South Carolina State Museum.
Mike Stoller> Hey there.
My name is Mike Stoller.
I am the Excavations and Collections Manager for the Charleston Center for Paleontology We are a nonprofit working here in association with the Mace Brown Museum of Natural History.
Davis> Hey, Scott, welcome to Curiosity Trek!.
Persons> Thanks for having me.
Davis> Now, the first question I have for you is do xenorophids have any ancestors?
Persons> They do!
So xenorophids belong to a larger group of whales called "odontocetes".
That means they're members of the toothed whale family, and that includes a lot of modern forms like dolphins, killer whales, belugas, and even sperm whales.
But they're part of the larger cetacean family, so they belong to the same group and have the same shared common ancestors as all modern day whales and dolphins.
Xenorophids were around towards the very, very end of what we call the Paleogene period.
That means they date back from about 23 to 30 million years ago.
So during the time of xenorophids, at the end of the Paleogene, where we're standing right now, would've been underwater.
So we were experiencing at the time prehistoric global warming.
The world is warmer, which means that a lot of the water that today is held up in polar ice caps, it melted and flooded the world's oceans so sea level was high.
And that's how we're able to find the bones of these animals preserved here in Charleston.
Because the sea was here, they would sink down to the bottom of it, get preserved in the fine sediments, and now the sea has drifted off, and you can find these ancient, ancient rock layers sitting right on the surface.
The diet of a xenorophid really depends on the particular xenorophid.
Most xenorophids have got teeth at the front of the mouth at least that are long and conical.
They would be really good at clamping down onto and holding tight, slippery prey, things like small fish.
Now others have got no teeth at all and may have been going after soft bodied things like squid.
And still others have larger, more impressive teeth, suggesting they were pushing it towards taking down bigger fish.
Xenorophids did have a lot of natural predators, so they lived at the point in time where there are other large tooth whales swimming through the oceans, and also the time when there is some large scary sharks.
Now, as is the case with most whales, they begin life with a lot more predators than they ended in.
And as xenorophids got larger, the number of animals in the environment that would dare to meddle with them goes down.
Stoller> So lifespan?
We don't have a whole lot of data to work with, but we do know these odontocetes like, say, the bottlenose dolphin can live upwards of 40, 50 years.
So we know that they have probably decent lifespans at the time.
In terms of how big these xenorophids could get.
Some of the larger species would be somewhere in the realm of 8.5 to 10 feet long.
Whereas some of the smaller species, little guys, would have been somewhere in the realm of 3 to 4ft.
So there's quite a range.
As far as we know, right now we have six genuses or geni.
And each one, is very different, but they're all within the same group.
They're all within the xenorophid family.
Davis> Any speculation as to why they chose this particular area to live in?
Yeah.
So, xenorophids would have picked this general area because it was a shallow marine setting.
Like I mentioned, it was this estuarine environment with lots of mud, lots of sand, like shallow water.
Where there's plenty of prey that they could feed on.
So this would have been a good environment for something like an early dolphin.
Davis> Now we get to the part I've personally been looking forward to the most: What made these xenorophid whales so unique?
For that, we'll need to take a closer look at their skulls.
Now, what does the name xenorophid mean in Latin?
Where did that name come from?
Persons> That's a great question!
It's actually a hard question to answer.
So "Xeno" is Greek for strange.
And so when we call them xenorophids, we mean that they're sort of "weirdos", they're "strangeness bearers".
And the origin of that name is a little bit unclear because Doctor Kellogg, the guy who named the first xenorophid doesn't actually specify in his monograph describing it what he meant by the name.
That is, what about xenorophids he found that was so strange, so unusual by comparison to other fossil whales.
But probably what he was referring to was the strangeness of their teeth.
So if you look at the jaw of a modern day dolphin, the teeth that you'll see at the very front of the mouth are the same as the teeth and very back of the mouth.
They all have teeth they've got the same basic form to them.
They're tall, they're conical.
They're good at holding onto fish.
In the skull of a xenorophid, the teeth at the front look fairly similar to the teeth of a modern dolphin, but the teeth at the back have this jagged sort of hacksaw form to them!
And rather than having a single root, they are double rooted.
Xenorophids we think are some of the oldest whales known to have the ability to echolocate.
And we think that based on the structure of their inner ear bones now, a lot of the soft tissue that's associated with being able to echolocate; to produce the sound and hear it doesn't normally fossilize, but the ear bones themselves of xenorophids are very sophisticated and they do wind up being preserved.
In order to echolocate, you've got to do two things: you've got to be able to produce the sound underwater and project it in a concentrated way.
And then you also have to be able to perceive it in a sophisticated enough way that you're able to actually locate distance and position.
And one of the ways you do that is actually by having a little bit of asymmetry in your skull, because you can use that asymmetry as far as where you perceive the sound with one ear and where you perceive it with the other in order to detect the distance.
Davis> Given their abundance in our region, it would have been awesome to see one of these xenorophids up close.
But sadly, we are about 23 million years too late.
It just so happens that the Palmetto State got lucky, in the sense that most xenorophid fossils are found right in our own backyard.
Now, what factors led to the xenorophids' extinction?
Stoller> So at this time in the Oligocene, and kind of the into the Oligocene-Miocene boundary, you had a lot of climactic changes that were happening: we were starting to get colder, sea level was rising and falling, so there were just a lot of things that were happening in the whales environment that weren't very conducive to its survival.
Generally, the skeletons that we find from the xenorophid family tend to be up towards kind of the Summerville-Ridgeville area.
We have a field site up in Ridgeville, and generally you're looking at areas that are kind of 2 to 3 feet below the surface so buried, but discoverable.
Davis> Are xenorophids a common family of whale or are they more on the rare side?
Persons> Xenorophids tend to be more on the rarer side.
They're only found in southeast North America as again, as far as we know that might change in the future.
We might find a xenorophid somewhere else in the world.
But as of right now, we can only really find them in southeast North America.
So places like South Carolina North Carolina and Virginia, which is really fascinating.
Davis> Well, Mike, thank you for this "splash" of enlightenment about xenorophid whales!
Stoller> Of course.
Thanks for having me.
Appreciate it!
On behalf of South Carolina ETV, thank you for joining us!
Persons> My pleasure!
Thanks for having me!
Davis> Thanks to Scott and Mike, we now have a clearer picture on this amazing family of ancient odontocetes found almost exclusively in South Carolina.
If you're an animal lover and find yourself in the Charleston area?
I highly recommend stopping into the Mace Brown Museum to see their impressive collection of xenorophid fossils.
If you enjoyed this dive into the history of these xenorophid whales?
All I have to say is... You're "whale-come"!
We take to the skies with this last stop on our journey!
I figured while I'm here in town we'll make a return to the Charleston Museum to examine another prehistoric animal which caught my attention on a previous visit.
The Charleston Museum's Natural History exhibit spotlights many examples of birds commonly found in our region, and even a few examples of birds now extinct.
One ancient bird skeleton in particular can be found hanging from the ceiling in the exhibit.
Between its massive wingspan and the spikey beak, this ancient bird catches museum visitors in awe.
What was this massive Lowcountry avifauna?
This is Pelagornis sandersi, the largest bird capable of flight ever known in world history.
Curator of Natural History Matthew Gibson joins us to fly through the history of this unique seabird.
Gibson> My name is Matthew Gibson, and I'm the Curator of Natural History here at the Charleston Museum.
Davis> Hey, Matt, thanks for joining us once again on Curiosity Trek!
Gibson> Well, thanks for having me!
Davis> Now, what time period or years was the Pelagornis seabird alive?
Gibson> So Pelagornis has a relatively long fossil record.
But our specific species is an Oligocene species, and it probably lived somewhere around 25 million years ago.
All birds are actually related to dinosaurs.
They're all modern descendants.
They come off the branch of the dinosaur family tree known as the theropod branch, which includes things like Tyrannosaurus and Velociraptor.
Davis> Is the Pelagornis related to any modern seabirds now?
Gibson> It's more closely related to our modern birds, and most modern research puts it somewhere near where geese and ducks fall on the bird family tree.
Davis> What would you say was the average lifespan of the Pelagornis?
Gibson> So most birds you're probably looking at 10 to 12 years perhaps, but we're not really sure about Pelagornis.
We only have a couple individuals and Some of the fossils we find are pretty incomplete, so we're not even quite sure of how long the Pelagornis's sort of life cycle would have been.
On average, despite having that very wide wingspan?
It would have weighed a lot less than you would expect.
Birds have to weigh less to be able to, you know, take to the air.
Estimates put it somewhere between 50-80 pounds so around the weight of a large dog.
Pelagornis was sort of a cavity nester or a cliff nester.
So more than likely it was not breeding here in South Carolina.
Most likely it was traveling across the Atlantic and maybe nesting somewhere, like, in the UK or in other areas.
Fossils for Pelagornis have been found along the coast of the Atlantic on either sides of it.
So there have been Pelagornis from Europe, I believe there might have been some from Africa and I know there have been some from Antarctica.
Davis> What did they typically eat?
Gibson> So, like our modern albatross, they kind of were skimming off the surface of the ocean.
So they were most likely picking up fish as well as small cephalopods like squid.
Davis> The most eye-catching features of the Pelagornis sandersi are its incredibly long wingspan, as well as these spikes found on the beak.
Despite looking like teeth, they are not teeth at all!
Gibson> Our estimates based off the skeleton that was discovered in Charleston.
The skeletal wing length is around 21ft.
But once you start tacking on the flight feathers, which were not preserved as fossils, you're probably looking at more like 24ft.
They would have spent most of their time gliding on ocean air currents, scouring for food.
And since they were able to kind of lock their wings into position they could fly over the ocean for long periods of time without really exerting a whole lot of energy.
So a lot of their time was basically just hang gliding over the Atlantic Ocean looking for something to eat.
Pelagornis is known as a "Pseudodontorn" or a false-toothed bird, and they have these raised, spike like projections that come off their beak that superficially look like teeth.
They're just more like just spikes.
And they would have used those to spear prey that was particularly slippery.
So, like I mentioned, squid those, once they got those in its mouth, they would really not be able to escape.
The other interesting thing is it has a ball and socket joint in its lower jaw that would allow it to expand its lower jaw larger so it could swallow things whole.
Sort of like a pelican.
Davis> For a seabird having such a massive wingspan, how is the Pelagornis sandersi able to achieve flight?
Unlike most other birds which flap their wings from a standstill position, The Pelagornis sandersi either had to run downhill into a headwind, or simply launch from a cliff using gravity and coastal winds, not unlike a hang glider.
Davis> Now, did the Pelagornis have any natural predators?
Gibson> Not really.
At least not that we know of.
But there were some instances where it could be preyed on by something else.
Even though it was a very capable flier, it couldn't easily take off or probably not even capable of taking off from the ocean.
So if at any point it was downed, it would have been prey for things like, hyper predatory whales like Xenorophus, and Ankylorhiza as well as saltwater crocodiles like Thecachampsa.
Davis> All formally recognized animal species have a Latin or scientific name.
The designation Pelagornis sandersi has a surprisingly direct link with Charleston!
Now, what does the name Pelagornis mean in Latin?
Where did that name come from?
Gibson> That's actually a kind of funny story.
So, Pelagornis has probably one of the least creative scientific names.
It basically translates to pelagic marine bird, or basically a marine bird that lives over the ocean.
Pelagornis sandersi is a specific species of Pelagornis.
There's only been one described and only from Charleston, South Carolina.
And is named for the previous curator of the Charleston Museum, Al Sanders.
There's a lot of different reasons why you would name a species after a person.
And he didn't describe it, he was one of the first people to help dig it out of the ground.
Another fun story: Our particular Pelagornis, so Pelagornis sandersi, was uncovered during expansion of the Charleston Airport.
So we actually collected the largest bird ever found, or at least largest wingspan from an airport!
Davis> Now, where are most Pelagornis fossils found in South Carolina?
Gibson> You can find them all along the coast.
They are very rare fossil.
Bird fossils are rare to begin with.
Bird bones are hollow.
They tend to break up easily, so finding a complete or even semi complete skeleton is pretty unheard of.
Most of the Pelagornis fossils that are found in the state are actually just singular small fragments of the beak.
Ours is actually the most complete Pelagornis discovered here.
In South Carolina, Pelagornis fossils are found in a formation known as the Chandler Bridge Formation which is approximately 25-28 million years old.
All the other fossils that are found in conjunction with it are all marine.
So we know that in places where the Chandler Bridge is exposed, you're dealing with environments that would have had been beneath the ocean.
So we find whale fossils, we find sea turtles and a lot of shelled organisms.
Due to that warmer climate there was less glacial ice at the poles, which is partially or maybe even exclusively why sea levels were significantly higher during that time period.
So now if we were to take that climate from the past and kind of scale it to now, we actually would be standing beneath the ocean.
Davis> The last birds of Genus Pelagornis died out around 2.5 million years ago, during the Early Pleistocene Era.
The causes for Pelagornis sandersi's disappearance remain a mystery.
Gibson> So we're not 100% sure what led to its specific extinction.
One generic rule for large bodied animals is they're very specific to their role in their environment or their niche, and even a small change in the environment, say, slight changes in temperature and climate, changes in coastlines could have put enough pressure that led to its eventual extinction.
The most interesting thing that I think that, our Pelagornis says is it kind of gives us sort of a story of this animal's sort of last moments.
And what's really interesting about ours is we actually have our skeleton preserved on one side.
So we have the whole skull, and then we have the right side, but we're missing the left side, which suggests that when this bird died, most likely it fell partially, into some soft ocean sediment.
That preserved side was buried, and then the other side was scavenged.
Pelagornis is a very rare snapshot, not only in the fact that it's like a bird, which is hard to preserve to begin with, but we have enough of the skeleton that we can mirror it, know exactly how the organism looked.
Davis> Once again, thank you for taking the time to meet with us today on Curiosity Trek!, and I hope that our fellow students will have learned something interesting today.
Gibson> I hope so!
I can't wait to meet you guys again next time.
Davis> Take care, Matt.
Now that we have the full story behind this magnificent ancient seabird, we can consider ourselves lucky that such a rare specimen has been preserved at the Charleston Museum.
If you are able to come visit and see this bird for yourself, the flight to Charleston would be worth it.
These Entelodont, Xenorophid whale, and Pelagornis sandersi fossils offer us some fascinating glimpses into what S.C.
was like long before the arrival of the earliest humans!
Which one did you enjoy the most?
I'm Andrew Davis.
Thank you for joining me on Curiosity Trek!
I certainly enjoyed today's journey and we hope you all did too!
With all of the history the Palmetto State contains... Where will our curiosities take us next?
Support for PBS provided by:
Curiosity Trek! is a local public television program presented by SCETV
Support for this program is provided by The ETV Endowment of South Carolina.















